How do you evaluate arguments? (2024)

The first step is to identify the argument that you want to evaluate. An argument is a set of statements that aim to persuade or convince someone of something. Usually, an argument has two main parts: a conclusion and one or more premises. The conclusion is the main claim that the argument tries to establish, while the premises are the reasons or evidence that support the conclusion. To identify the argument, look for words or phrases that indicate the conclusion, such as "therefore", "so", "hence", or "thus". Also, look for words or phrases that indicate the premises, such as "because", "since", "for", or "as". Sometimes, the conclusion or the premises may be implied or hidden, so you may need to infer them from the context or the tone of the speaker or writer.

The next step is to analyze the structure of the argument. This means to examine how the premises and the conclusion are related and organized. There are different types of arguments, such as deductive, inductive, causal, analogical, or ethical. Each type of argument has its own rules and criteria for validity and soundness. For example, a deductive argument is valid if the conclusion follows necessarily from the premises, and sound if the premises are true. An inductive argument is strong if the conclusion is probable or likely based on the premises, and cogent if the premises are reliable and relevant. A causal argument is valid if the cause and the effect are logically connected, and sound if the cause and the effect are empirically verified. An analogical argument is strong if the analogy is relevant and similar, and cogent if there are no significant differences or counterexamples. An ethical argument is valid if the moral principles and values are consistent and coherent, and sound if the moral principles and values are justified and accepted.

The final step is to evaluate the content of the argument. This means to assess the truth, accuracy, relevance, and sufficiency of the premises and the conclusion. To do this, you need to consider your background knowledge, logic, evidence, sources, context, purpose, and audience. Ask yourself questions such as: Are the premises true or false? Are they relevant or irrelevant to the conclusion? Are they sufficient or insufficient to justify the conclusion? Are there any hidden assumptions or biases? Are there any alternative explanations or perspectives? Are there any ethical implications or consequences? By following these steps and tips, you can evaluate arguments more effectively and critically. Furthermore, you can hone your own argumentation skills by applying the same criteria to your own arguments. Evaluating arguments is not only a skill but also a habit of mind that can help you become a better thinker, communicator, and learner.

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Critical Thinking

+ Follow

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.